GEOG 104
Compare Four Online Maps

OBJECTIVE: In this exercise, you are to compare the street network contents of four maps (really databases), for a place that you know well, as represented in several current on-line mapping services:

I suspect that you will find that even such authoritative maps disagree on basic facts. And I hope that you take to heart the old cartographic aphorism "When the terrain and the map disagree, trust the terrain."

The emphasis here is on the contents. that you might consider are:

Secondarily, you may notice differences in the kinds of content included, the graphic design of the displays and symbols, the tools provided to aid the user, the information privided to the user (scale? grid coordinates? latitude and longitude?), etc. that would affect the utility in any given context. They probably reflect intended use of the maps.

Work with comparable scales, probably something larger than 1:24,000, maybe 1:10,000 or (better) "zoomed-in" far enough that the streets are labled. It's probably fairer to compare the on-screen maps rather than printed versions. (I'm not sweating whether you have a color printer or not, you needn't either.)

The National Map Viewer a web interface to maps from USGS data.

Hints... Overlays. Clear Map. Pan buttons. GIS Toolbox. "Base Map", "Imagery", and "Blank" buttons.

Open Street Map offers maps and data based on user contributed information.

Hints... "Zoom and hand drag pan" to select the area. "Export" Tab, select either the Mapnik or the Osmarender Image, and the PNG or JPG format. Note that you have bounding rectangle and scale (as a representative fraction like 1:27500) on screen here. Hit the "Export" button. It should return an image file that you can save or cut and paste from your browser.

Googe Maps offers maps based on Google's database of geographic features.

Hints... "Zoom and hand drag pan" to select the area. "Print" link. Toggle Satelite vs Map vs Terrain etc.

Yahoo Maps offers printable maps based apparently on Navteq's data.

Hints... "Zoom and hand drag pan" to select the area. "Print" "send" and "Save" links. Map, Hybrid, Satellite buttons. Meta-map navigation. Latitude and Longitude in the URL.

Google Earth

Google Earth seems to have a different set of street data than does Google Maps. Do they talk with each other?

Hints... GE requires a download and install and may be getting ahead of ourselves but, if you are game or already using it... turn on the "Roads" layer, leave the others off, and see what it shows you. Don't be fooled by waht you can see in the image data, look for their vectors.

Apple Maps

In 2012 Apple rolled-out a go-it-alone mapping system (kicking-out Google) and users were disappointed. Since then Apple has been shedding project managers and buying-up mapping technology (TomTom, Embark, HopStop, Locationary, etc) to build capablity. Here, you are on your own. I don't have a smart phone. But I am curious as to where they stand.

Assignment Tasks & Strategy Instructions:

  1. Pick a small area with which you are familiar, of a place of your choice that you know pretty well (like your hometown or current neighborhood).
  2. "Zoom-in" to the same area using the websites to compare maps of approximately the same scale and coverage. (I.e., have the maps to show the same geographic area in the same screen area.)
  3. Compare the maps. See suggestions above.
  4. Print each of the maps (if you can, maybe via screen grabs or saving them as image files) and mark on them where you spot differences.
  5. Write a brief (~1 page) report on what you found. Include your name and the placename, the latitude and longitude, and the approximate scale of the maps, along with the differences and similarities you note among the different sources.
  6. Staple the pages together and turn them in.

N.B. If you get stuck, let me know.