| A | B | C | |
| Effort | Attempts all activities to the best of their ability. | Attempts all activities. | Generally attempts activities. |
| Participation | Provides valuable contributions to discussion. Asks insightful questions. | Contributes to discussion. Asks questions. | Hesitant to contribute to discussion or ask questions. |
| Responsibility | Is prepared and on time. | Is usually prepared and on time. | Is sometimes prepared and on time. |
| Team Work | Coordinates with and assists other students in gathering information and peer-review of papers. | Sometimes coordinates with and assists other students. | Works alone. |