ES/WS
390: GENDER AND RACE IN U.S. SOCIETY (E-Focus)
FALL 2009
ARCH 101A
T, Th 9 am to 10:15am
Dr. Monisha Das Gupta
George Hall 306
Ph: 956-2914
dasgupta@hawaii.edu
Office
Hours: Th 3-5 pm, F 10 - 11 am and by appointment
For all updates on the
syllabus see: http://www2.hawaii.edu/~dasgupta/
(The page can also be accessed through the Ethnic Studies Home Page)
Course
Description:
This course looks at the
interlinked social processes that make gender
and race in the United States. How have social relations like
colonization, slavery, civil rights, and migration shaped social
institutions like the courts, media, education, and health
care? How have people fought back against gender and racial
subordination? We examine particular historical contexts and
contemporary issues to answer these questions. Thus, the entire course
asks you to reflect on the ethics of building a society that is free of
racial and gender discrimination. In doing, so we come to realize that
concepts of race and gender change over time and that people do not
experience their racial and gender identities apart from each other.
Furthermore, one’s race and gender also send out messages about one’s
sexuality and economic class. Thus, the thematic units in the
course build on each other to communicate that:
a) Experiences of gender and
race are also mediated by the role of
sexuality, class and nationality. Therefore, a comprehensive
vision of social justice must take into account the intersections of
different types of social hierarchies.
b) This intersectional
approach helps us place the contemporary experiences of different
racial groups in historical context.
Contemporary
Ethical Issues Focus
Most often we use a binary
moral framework of “good” or “bad” to judge
the contemporary social problems that face us. Social problems,
like racism and sexism, are multidimensional. To understand the
complex roots of these problems and to effectively address them, we
need finer tools that are based in ethics, rather than morality, so
that we can see that there are more than two opposite sides of an
issue. In this class, we will focus on the complexities of
the ethical questions that each of the units raises, to learn how to
develop appropriate ethical positions. In doing so, we will learn
how to bridge the gap between normativity (how society should be) and
reality (the way society is).
- Please use my office
hours. If you cannot make those,
make an appointment to see me. One-to-one meetings enable us to
discuss your ideas, help you with any difficulty you face with the
course material, and help me to get to know you better.
- Students who have
special needs should make an appointment to see me within the first
week of class so that we can ensure your full participation.
Required
Readings:
WS/ES 390 Reader is available at Professional Image, 2633 S. King St,
973-6599.
The following books are available at Revolution Books 2626 King Street,
944-3106.
1) David Stannard. 2006. Honor Killing: Race,
Rape, and Clarence Darrow's Spectacular Last Case. Penguin.
[Stannard
in Course Outline]
2) Andrea Smith. 2005. Conquest: Sexual Violence and
American Indian Genocide. South End Press. [Smith in
Course
Outline]
3) Nadia Kim. 2008. Imperial Citizens: Koreans and
Race from Seoul to LA. Stanford University Press. [Kim in Course
Outline]
Learning
Objectives:
• Identify
the ethical issues embedded in race and gender relations in U.S. society
• Evaluate
the range of anti-racist and anti-sexist
responses in order to arrive at ethical means of social action
• Link
historical events and issues to contemporary
concerns; trace change over time in the ethical frameworks of
antiracist and anti-sexist efforts
• Think
relationally across racial and gender groups
• Become
critical thinkers. The course
challenges you to move away from description to analysis by learning to
ask “what,” “why,” “how” questions about the material.
• Develop
writing and oral presentation skills
Getting a
major, minor or certificate in Ethnic Studies and Women’s Studies:
Many of you have been taking
Ethnic Studies or Women’s Studies courses
that qualify you for a major, minor, or certificate in these
fields. ES/WS 390 fulfills Ethnic Studies’ course requirements in
Category C and Women’s Studies’ requirement of coursework with a focus
on gender, race and ethnicity in transnational perspective. To
learn how to get a major, minor, or certificate in Ethnic Studies go to
the Ethnic Studies Academic Programs webpage and contact Prof. Ibrahim
Aoude at aoude@hawaii.edu or at
956-4000. For Women’s Studies, go to
Women’s Studies Degrees webpage and contact Prof. Kathy Ferguson at
kferguso@hawaii.edu or at 956-6933.
Assignments
and Grade Distribution (Total=100)
Weeks
2-15: Weekly Assignments: 10 points
10/6 : Mid Term
20
points
11/5: Gender Violence
paper 10
points
12/1: Movie Review
10
points
Oral Group Presentations
10 points
12/14: Research Paper
30 points
Participation
10 points
Course
Requirements:
Attendance:
Attendance is mandatory.
You are not supposed to be anywhere else
during the scheduled class period. An attendance sheet will be
passed around at the beginning of class. You cannot sign the
sheet if you come in late. Early departures or coming late to
class — unless by permission — will be considered as absences.
You are allowed two unpenalized absence during the semester (this
amounts to a week’s worth of class) but in all cases of absence, you
need to inform me via e-mail. I reserve the right to fail a
student whose attendance is irregular. Please understand that if
you are absent then you obviously cannot participate in class.
Your absences will be reflected in the grade you receive for
participation.
Participation:
Speaking and active listening
in class counts for participation.
The success of this E focus class depends on honest and respectful
discussion that engages with the ideas presented in the readings,
lectures, videos, and by your classmates. The grade of students
who do not participate in class discussion will automatically drop to a
“B.” If you have problems speaking in a classroom setting, please
talk to me about it.
Readings:
You must come to class having
done the assigned reading. You
cannot participate in class discussions or do the weekly assignments
without doing the readings. This is an upper level class.
In taking it, you are making a commitment to come to class
prepared. Please bring the readings we are covering on a
particular day (books or reader or both) to class.
Writing:
All written work for this
course needs to be word-processed,
grammatical, free of spelling errors, and well-organized. All
direct quotations taken from the readings must be cited. A paper
that does not cite direct quotes taken from the readings by author and
page number or that inadequately paraphrases the readings will receive
an "F."
Weekly assignments
(15%): You will submit a response (max 1 page)
to the readings and an overall discussion question for the weeks marked
in the Course Outline. The response must cover all the weekly
readings and must reflect critical thinking. It should not be a
summary of the readings. You will end the assignment with a
“why/how/what” question on the overall themes of the readings. There
are no make-ups for discussion questions and questions submitted by
e-mail or dropped off by a friend are not acceptable. See the online
syllabus for guidelines on doing this assignment.
Mid Term (15%): I
will set essay questions based on the material
covered in class for your midterm. The midterm will be an open
book take home. You will be allowed to consult the relevant texts and
class notes to answer the questions. You will need to cite all your
sources and ideas.
Movie Review (10%): I
will provide you with a list of movies from
which you will select one and write a review using the analytical tools
used in the course.
Research Paper (30%):
I will provide a list of suggested topics. Students need to meet
with me during my office hours to discuss
their research project at least twice
during the semester. The
research project will be based on primarily on library research and
scholarly sources. On the 4th week of class
you will submit a research topic and a list of books, scholarly,
articles, and web resources. You will work systematically on the
project for the rest of the semester. This means reading the
books and articles you have listed for your project and taking notes on
them, doing your interviews, collecting archival material, watching and
taking notes on shows or movies. There are no extensions on the
research paper deadline.
Group Exercise (10 points):
Each student will sign up for
one of the topics listed below to
formulate group exercises that will allow students to deliberate on the
range of ethical positions that one can take on the topic. The
topics are based on the materials you will be covering in class. The
leaders in charge of the topic will need to ensure that a) students
discuss the ethical dilemmas and arrive at ways to address them; b)
everyone present gets an opportunity to participate in discussions and
share their ideas. See online syllabus for guidelines and
resources for this assignment.
• Moral
Panics: Media, Public Opinion and the Rule of Law in the Massie Case
•
Reproductive Choice, Reproductive Rights
•
Gender and Culture
• Cultural
Appropriation, Cultural Appreciation
• Imperial
Subjects/Global Citizens: Koreans in Seoul and LA
Extra credit: (4 credits per
semester)
You can earn extra credit by attending a maximum of four events on campus that I will
announce in class or post on this page. To get credit you need to
submit short write up within a week of the event. The write-up
should explain the event and your response to it, including a question
you asked or wanted to ask.
Policies:
Late papers:
All assignments are due at the
beginning of the class. The dates on
which the papers are due are firm deadlines. You will lose 1/3 of
a grade for every day that an assignment is late. For eg., if you
submit a A- paper a day late, the grade will be scaled down to a B+.
Absences:
Attendance is mandatory.
Academic honesty:
Any infraction of codes of
academic honesty will lead to sanctions from
the instructor. You will receive a failing grade if you copy or submit
other people's work, or do not properly attribute ideas that are not
original to you. Please
read Section H of Impermissible Behavior of the
Student Conduct Code for familiarizing yourself with what constitutes
academic
dishonesty http://www.hawaii.edu/student/conduct/imper.html. See also http://studentaffairs.manoa.hawaii.edu/policies/
to understand the working of the Academic Grievance Procedure.
Course
Outline:
Unit I:
Core Concepts
Week 1
8/25: Introductions;
8/27: AAA
Statement (Download);
Lorber, “Social construction of gender” (Download)
Week 2
• 9/3:
Weekly assignment #1: In your own words, briefly explain racialization
and intersectionality. Why does Lipsitz use "possessive
investment" to talk about Whiteness?
9/1: Omi and Winant, “Racial
Formation” (Reader); Zinn and Dill, “Theorizing Difference from
Multiracial feminism” (Reader)
9/3: Okihiro “Is Yellow Black
or White?” (Reader); Lipsitz, “Bill
Moore’s Body” and “The Possessive Investment in Whiteness” (Reader)
Week 3
• 9/10
Weekly assignment #2:
How do race and ethnicity come together in "cultural racism" and what
examples of cultural racism do you see in McIntosh's list.
Breifly comment on Giroux's argument that we don't yet live in a
post-racial society in the U.S.
9/8: Pierre,
“Black Immigrants in the United States and Cultural Narratives of
Ethnicity” (Download)
9/10: McIntosh, “White
Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack,”
(Reader); Giroux, “Youth
and the Myth of a Post-Racial Society Under
Barack Obama” (Download)
Unit II:
Honor Killing: Race, Masculinity, and Femininity
Week 4
• 9/17
Weekly assignment #3: With an example taken from Honor Killing
show how either U.S. military presence or tourism was racializing
military personnel based in Hawai’i, Native Hawaiians, and Asian
immigrants. In your discussion, mark how class, status, and
gender play into the ways in which these groups are racialized.
Why is it important to pay
attention to racial coding and racial violence when thinking about
gender violence? At what moment, according to Angela Davis, did
the myth of the black rapist emerge?
• Research
topic and list of references due
9/15: Stannard, Chs 1-6
9/17: Stannard Chs 6-10;
Davis, “Race Racism and the Myth of the Black Rapist” (Reader)
Week 5
• 9/24
Weekly assignment # 4: How does the escalated portrayal of Hawai’i as a dangerous place simmering with racial tensions even after the hung jury in the first trial, and the lynching of Joe Kahahawai help you unpack a moral panic?
9/22: Stannard: Chs 11-15
9/24: Stannard: Chs 16-21, Yamanaka, “Kala gave me
anykine advice” (Reader)
Videos: Impact of Massie Case and excerpts from Noho Hewa: The Wrongful Occupation of Hawai'i
RESOURCES: Prisons: Chesney-Lind and Brown, Hawaii incarceration rates
UARC: Manoa Faculty Senate on UARC , President McClain's recommendations on UARC (Feb 2006), Prof Ruth Dawson on Ethics of UARC,
Keever, UARC and Agent Orange, Ethnic Studies Statement on UARC, DMZ Hawaii Flyer
Stryker Brigade: McAvoy, Army to Keep Stryker Brigade in Hawaii, DMZ Hawaii, Aloha 'Aina, Stop the Strykers, DMZ Hawaii, Militarized Sites in Hawai'i
Week 6
• 10/1
Weekly assignment # 5: Why is the Massie case seen as a critical
turning point in Hawai'i's history? After learning about the
case, does your understanding of "local" identity change?
• 10/1 Group
Exercise: Moral Panics
9/29: Stannard, 22-28
10/1: Review Stannard
Unit III:
Violence against Women and Sexual Economies
Week 7
• 10/6 Mid Term due in class 10/6 (20
pts)
10/6: Smith, Chs 1
10/8: Smith, Ch 2; Adrienne Davis, “’Don’t
let nobody bother yo’ principle,’” (Reader);
Video: No!
Week 8
10/13: Smith, Ch 3 and 4
10/15: Smith, Ch 5,
Roberts, “The Dark Side of Birth Control”
Week 9
10/22
Group Exercise: Reproductive Choice, Reproductive Rights
10/20: “From Norplant to
Contraceptive Vaccines” (Reader); Chavez,
“Latina Sexuality, Reproduction, and Fertility as Threats” (Reader);
Making Contact on National Radio Project, “Guard us
All?” (Download)
10/22: Smith, Ch 8
Week 10
10/27: Rudrappa, “Finding our
Home in the World” (Reader); Smith Ch 7
10/29: Rudrappa,
“Madness, Diasporic Difference, and State Violence: Explaining Filicide
in American Courts”
(Download)
Unit IV:
Transnational Contours of Empire
Week 11
• 11/5 Short
Essay on Gender Violence (10 points)
• 11/5
Weekly Assignment # 6
11/3: Review; MacFarquhar, Abused Muslim Women in US Gain Advocates (download; emailed article)
11/5: David and Ayouby,
“Studying the Exotic Other in the Classroom” (download)
Video: Under One Sky: Arab Women in North America
Talk about the Hijab
Week 12
• 11/12
Weekly Assignment # 7
• 11/12 Group Exercise: Gender and Culture
11/10: Said, “Orientalism”
(Reader); Kim, Ch 1 pp. 1-19
11/12: Kim, Ch 2
Week 13
• 11/19
Weekly assignment # 8
• 11/19
Group Exercise: Cultural Imperialism, Cultural Appropriation, Cultural
Appreciation
11/17: Kim, Ch 3
11/ 19: Kim Ch 4
Week 14
• 11/24
Weekly assignment # 9
11/24: Kim, Ch 5
11/26: THANKSGIVING BREAK: Work on Research Paper and keep up with Kim readings
Week 15
• 12/1: Movie Review due in class (10 points) + 1 para thesis (argument) for research paper
• 12/3
Weekly assignment #10
12/1: Kim, Ch 7
12/ 3: Kim Ch 8
Week 16
• 12/8 Group
Exercise: Imperial
Subjects/Global Citizens
• 12/10 Xtra Credit Weekly Assignment (2 points)
12/8: Ch 9
12/10: Last Thoughts
RESEARCH PAPER (30 pts) DUE ON
12/14 (M), GEORGE HALL 301, 3PM
* This syllabus is subject to
minor changes